Navigating AI-Generated Information: How Information Literacy Can Contribute to Critical Thinking and Responsible AI Use

About the Author: Kristy Nowak, MLIS, is the First-Year Experience and Student Success Librarian at CSU. She teaches information literacy, with a focus on the skills that incoming students need to be successful in college. She typically teaches AI as it relates to information evaluation, often using AI content evaluation strategies to support student development of critical information literacy skills. She also researches bias in information systems, and has conducted research with undergraduate researchers to generate and analyze AI content for systemic bias.

Photo of Kristy Nowak

AI is an ever-increasing part of the information landscape, and students need to be proficient in navigating and understanding AI-generated content. While AI literacy skills are new in certain respects, they are also heavily grounded in pre-existing information literacy skills such as information evaluation, understanding information systems, and navigating the context and authority behind information sources (ex. the Framework for Information Literacy in Higher Education). Working with AI literacy from the foundation of information literacy skills helps students develop critical thinking, responsible information use, and more successfully navigate the new information landscape.

AI as an ‘Information Source’

While AI and Large Language Models (LLMs) have been around for years, there are still a lot of misunderstandings about what these systems are and how they work. For example, there is a lot of debate about whether they are ‘information sources’ and these debates have real-world implications for how the systems are used in research and daily life. Because LLMs are designed to make content that sounds plausible (but the systems do not have an orientation towards facts or truth), there is genuine debate about how they relate to information or whether their outputs can be described as informational. However, there can be little debate that LLMs are being used to find, understand, and create new information. According to a National Bureau of Economic Research working paper which analyzed the questions/prompts people inputted into ChatGPT from May 2024-June 2025, approximately 50% fell into the categories of “practical guidance” or “seeking information.” Both categories demonstrate information-seeking behavior, indicating that these tools are being used as an information source and, therefore, it’s essential that students are able to flexibly apply information literacy skills to using and interpreting AI content. 

Classroom Activities to Support AI/Information Literacy

There are a number of simple activities that can be integrated into classes which will help students develop AI-relevant information literacy skills. These activities bolster both a practical ability to use AI and a critical approach to understanding and evaluating AI-generated content. For example, it can often be extremely helpful to integrate information tracking activities into class sessions where students may be dealing with AI-cited sources. While tracking down original sources has always been an important part of the research process, it’s taken on new urgency and new strategies in the AI environment, where AI hallucinations can often lead to fake sources and/or falsely attributed information. Students can practice locating original sources and comparing the information from the AI claims and the original source. This activity can help students understand the range of possible issues with AI citations/AI-generated information, which go beyond fake sources and include mismatches between the source and attributed information, untraceable information, and poorly chosen citations/resources. As students practice tracking and comparing information cited in AI, they also develop transferable skills that will help them evaluate information from any source and track scholarly conversations.

This activity, as well as many others, can help students develop a better understanding of how these systems actually work. Since these systems are based on probability models, it can also be useful for students to consider/discuss the implications of these systems (ex. what voices/regions/languages/perspectives may be highlighted or excluded) and analyze AI-generated content for specific perspectives or biases. It can also be useful to compare, for example, search results from an academic database with the sources cited by an AI tool. One particularly useful information evaluation tool is SIFT, an information evaluation acronym created by Mike Caulfield, which encourages students to take steps including spending a quick moment to think about how they are reacting to the output/information, tracing sources, and evaluating the source. Importantly, SIFT also encourages students to find better coverage, which can be particularly helpful when an AI tool is only presenting one perspective or a narrow range of resources. 

Support and Resources from CSU Libraries

Finally, always remember that CSU Libraries has information literacy experts who are available to help support AI literacy for instructors and students! We can visit your class(es) to teach some of these skills with hands-on activities, provide one-on-one help, help revise or develop assignments, or provide Canvas-integrated modules. We have extensive experience working with students and helping develop information literacy skills, including in the new AI environment. See some of our key resources below:

Please reach out to us with any questions and/or include library resources on your syllabus! We look forward to working with you!